Will New York Be Underwater by 2050?

14. mars. 2020
444 252 Ganger

Be one of the first 500 people to sign up with this link and get 20% off your subscription with Brilliant.org! brilliant.org/realengineering/
New streaming platform: watchnebula.com/

Vlog channel: notown.info/love/Met4qY3027v8KjpaDtDx-g

Patreon:
www.patreon.com/user?u=2825050&ty=h
Facebook:
facebook.com/realengineering1
Instagram:
instagram.com/brianjamesmcmanus
Reddit:
www.reddit.com/r/RealEngineering/
Twitter:
twitter.com/thebrianmcmanus
Discord:
discord.gg/s8BhkmN

Get your Real Engineering shirts at: standard.tv/collections/real-engineering

Credits:
Writer/Narrator/Animator: Brian McManus
Editor: Dylan Hennessy
Camera Operator: Dave Whiskus (notown.info/love/NwJDNN4ib8zqp5Apcj4I9w)
Animator: Mike Ridolfi (www.moboxgraphics.com/)
Sound: Graham Haerther (haerther.net/)
Thumbnail: Simon Buckmaster twitter.com/forgottentowel


References:

[1]www1.nyc.gov/site/cdbgdr/about/About%20Hurricane%20Sandy.page
[2] Page 12 s-media.nyc.gov/agencies/sirr/SIRR_spreads_Hi_Res.pdf
[3] Page 13 s-media.nyc.gov/agencies/sirr/SIRR_spreads_Hi_Res.pdf
[4] sealevel.nasa.gov/understanding-sea-level/global-sea-level/thermal-expansion
[5] Page 49 s-media.nyc.gov/agencies/sirr/SIRR_spreads_Hi_Res.pdf
[6] www.deptofnumbers.com/gdp/new-york/
[7] Page 51 s-media.nyc.gov/agencies/sirr/SIRR_spreads_Hi_Res.pdf
[8] Adapting Cities To Sea Level Rise - Stefan Al
[9] www.hastingsgov.org/sites/hastingsonhudsonny/files/uploads/bbp_storm_resilience_-_final.pdf
[10] www.nydailynews.com/new-york/queens/city-building-sand-wall-rockaway-article-1.1376159
Thank you to AP Archive for access to their archival footage.

Music by Epidemic Sound: epidemicsound.com/creator

Songs:

Atomic Numbers 1 - August Wilhelmsson
The Return Journey - Francis Wells
Travellers - Ran the Man
Computer Wiz - Marten Moses
Missing Pieces - Jean Leonti
Thank you to my patreon supporters: Adam Flohr, Henning Basma, Hank Green, William Leu, Tristan Edwards, Ian Dundore, John & Becki Johnston. Nevin Spoljaric, Jason Clark, Thomas Barth, Johnny MacDonald, Stephen Foland, Alfred Holzheu, Abdulrahman Abdulaziz Binghaith, Brent Higgins, Dexter Appleberry, Alex Pavek, Marko Hirsch, Mikkel Johansen, Hibiyi Mori. Viktor Józsa, Ron Hochsprung

Kommentarer
  • If we are lucky, it will be gone.

    rick haydenrick haydenDag siden
  • if land prices fall, it is true.

    S. SpeesS. Spees4 dager siden
  • *"Will New York Be Underwater by 2050?"* Answer: *NO.* Any other questions...? --an Engineer

    Mogumbo GonoMogumbo Gono4 dager siden
  • Lets scare some people😟😟😟😟

    master marinermaster mariner8 dager siden
  • Is this "will new York be under water by 2050" or "how to prevent new York from flooding because of storms surges"?????

    laure laurelaure laureMåned siden
  • Do you know the Jason-Topex-Popsidon satellite says the sea level rise is 3.2 mm/yr about 1 foot centuryand it is backed uo by tidal gauges!

    abel garciaabel garciaMåned siden
  • We also need to start planting vast forests!!!

    A1MYT MCOCA1MYT MCOCMåned siden
  • no end card?

    Al S.Al S.Måned siden
  • You know what’s funny about the East River park plan? The city just decided to cancel it. No reason given. The community is pissed off.

    Spencer BergSpencer BergMåned siden
  • Measuring the level of the sea is not as simple as he makes it sound. The area where you place the ruler, could rise or lower do to various reasons that have nothing to do with the sea level. These variables would need to be addressed.

    Max PowersMax Powers2 måneder siden
  • So where's the answer to the title question?

    ImaskarDonoImaskarDono2 måneder siden
  • Talking to friends about this topic...they say they don't care, "we don't live there". Problem is I said, "if NY floods where do you think those folks are gonna go?" Friends got real quiet...."yeah, that's right" I said. "We gonna be surrounded by them." Now we all are praying NY don't flood. No offense intended.

    nobody ismynamenobody ismyname2 måneder siden
  • Yes because Greta told us so, must be true and a lot of city will by submerged under the sea. Wait, no she told in 2019 that the life on earth will end in 10 years: 2029. It's true because even Bill gates told the same, but because OS pandemics. I wear 4 masks even inside my car, because is safer for the people I love

    A ZA Z2 måneder siden
  • Or plan ''B'' preparing to move inland relocate the city or seek new industrial hub to spare just in the case you lost this location because you cant just built a wall like this forever as the sea level will rise up until there are no more ice sheet in Antarctica or in the Arctic to melt unless you stop destroying the climate and the atmosphere which is very difficult as human are addict in industrial system that bring them benefits only rather than thinking about the sake of the world or the nature and if they change the way to produce their goods in the factory without destroying the atmosphere or the nature it will reduce their income or benefit and also because those stupid fokking millionaire dont care about any alert situation as they have many plenty of house and estate so they can relocate or move out anytime and another unpleasant reason to know that they shut the mouth of the politicians with many ''0'' as a cashes lol...sincerely not joking .

    Perseus IXPerseus IX2 måneder siden
  • Every disaster to America is good news for me

    masyolamasyola2 måneder siden
  • It's sad that you are now propagating lies and fake science. There is no man caused global warming.

    Wesley MoreiraWesley Moreira2 måneder siden
  • At the current rate of sea-level rise, which is linear w/ r²=0.98, water will reach the base of Manhattan in 2530 and the base of Time's Square in 6294. It can't (there's not enough) but if the water continued to rise indefinitely the Statue of Liberty will underwater in the year 31475. climate.nasa.gov/vital-signs/sea-level/

    BobBob2 måneder siden
  • It’s like people think estimates arent made, precautions arent taken....when and if it ever gets as bad as people say, we will adapt. Dams built, maybe even new opportunities for energy production in structures preventing an “overflow”

    Uncle B.Uncle B.2 måneder siden
  • No

    Uncle B.Uncle B.2 måneder siden
  • Bull Shit

    I Love Global Warming God Bless The USAI Love Global Warming God Bless The USA2 måneder siden
    • Wdym?

      NoNo2 måneder siden
  • Thanks for mentioning nuclear as part of the solution.

    TheTogo1500TheTogo15002 måneder siden
  • Only financially.

    drewtronicsdrewtronics2 måneder siden
  • One can only hope. New York is mostly garbage. Same with Cali.

    JeevoJeevo3 måneder siden
  • Hurricane Noah

    Mary ChiclanaMary Chiclana3 måneder siden
  • U made this on my birthday lol 😂

    Somitra SharmaSomitra Sharma3 måneder siden
  • And why would the planning, approval and permitting process take 30 years? Because the environmental impact studies would take a decade in themselves even if there were no opposition (and you KNOW there will be opposition).

    sifridbassoonsifridbassoon3 måneder siden
  • This won't happen because climate change is nonesense. Climate always changes, it's normal. We aren't going to be able to stop it.

    MineCrafterCityMineCrafterCity3 måneder siden
    • Obviously it changes but we accelerate it

      NoNo2 måneder siden
  • If people deny climate change, you won't change their mind. They made their choice based on their innate, deepest world views. Truth has nothing to do with it.

    Jon BarJon Bar3 måneder siden
  • Lex Luthor's dream

    Phillip LeechPhillip Leech3 måneder siden
  • Liberals: “Watch out for rising oceans because of global warming!” All liberals: “Let’s all live on the east and west coast.”

    mrmatalinomrmatalino3 måneder siden
    • conservatives: why do all you libs live on the cost lines if you are so afraid of the global warming? also conservatives: (not even remotely concerned about when global warming starts pushing all of the libs inland.)

      bp qdbp qd2 måneder siden
  • Here we go more propaganda. Maybe you should try to stop all the volcanic venting in the oceans and under the glaciers.

    politicallyincorrectROBpoliticallyincorrectROB3 måneder siden
  • Maybe you should explain, that NYC used to be 400 feet above sea level, and some of that rise is still in motion. Rather then suggesting names to call them. What most people dismiss is the sci-fi movie pictures of the Statue of Liberty underwater in 20 years. Besides, how many times have Scientist and Al Gore predicted a tipping point of no return and ice free Arctic seas. People lose faith after a while. www.americanthinker.com/legacy_assets/articles/old_root/Global%20warming%20epihany.JPG

    Wade PatrickWade Patrick3 måneder siden
  • will it be underwater? We can only hope. If we get lucky LA, SF, DC and Chicago will be as well. Problem solved.

    BA_300_AACBA_300_AAC3 måneder siden
  • Short Answer: No. Examine any legitimate graph of sea level rise since the last glacial maximum around 21,000 years ago, and you'll see the sea level has rise roughly 130 meters due to ice melt. However, in the last third of that, say, 7,000 years, it's only risen roughly 4 meters, and that's for one very good reason: There's hardly any ice left to melt. Yes, Greenland... And Antarctica... But if you examine the ice core data, neither one are going to give up appreciable portions of their ice before the next plunge into an ice age, and Greenland's surface area just isn't that big at 2.166 M km^2 compared to Antarctica's 14.2 M km^2. Actual, factual, supportable, peer-reviewed SCIENCE supports a sea level rise of, at most, another 3 meters (10 feet) over the next 10,000, but ONLY if we don't plunge into another ice age before then, which, given the periodicity of the timeline over the last 5 ice ages, approaches a probability of 100%. More likely, it'll be within the next 200 to 2,000 years. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sea_level_rise#/media/File:Post-Glacial_Sea_Level.png

    Justin CaseJustin Case3 måneder siden
  • 3:55 and where's the link to the Netherlands video?

    George CarlinGeorge Carlin3 måneder siden
  • HAHAHAHAHA, wasn't it already supposed to be.

    Jacob OJalaJacob OJala3 måneder siden
  • I thought it was supposed to be under water already and the world would be out of oil.

    Conservative BLMConservative BLM3 måneder siden
  • What would be the downside of flooding this democrat shithole ? Howard Stern ...gone, Cumo bros ..gone , its all good

    BILL StecikBILL Stecik3 måneder siden
  • The Atlanteans called, and they want their city back !

    SubaruForester2015SubaruForester20153 måneder siden
  • There is no increase in frequency of hurricanes: pjmedia.com/columns/madhav-khandekar-and-tom-harris/2020/12/05/fact-check-hurricanes-are-not-strengthened-by-our-co2-emissions-n1192711 Do your homework. Sea levels have been rising 0.8mm per year for 250 years. Sea level rise is linear. Why would you think this is a danger in the future? So far there is no evidence that extra PPM CO2 in the upper troposphere is causing any sea level rise above background level since the little ice age. See: notown.info/two/video/3puYlJ1gqrNmqqM.html

    Cutting Through The NoiseCutting Through The Noise3 måneder siden
  • I'm gonna say: no.

    sesssess3 måneder siden
  • Infrastructural engineering is the answer to human advancement.

    Sean HaggardSean Haggard3 måneder siden
  • 1.7 Trillion stimulus package. But 25 Billion is too much.

    Sean HaggardSean Haggard3 måneder siden
  • More climate alarmist bullshit. Florida was supposed to have flooded by now which it hasn't. So the idea of New York being under water in 30 years is about as credible as any failed dooms-day prediction.

    herrschaftg35herrschaftg353 måneder siden
  • This have been threaten with since i was a kid, that's 40 years ago... and it have still not come true. Now all the suddenly its a real deal, yet again. My forth climate death and humanity's extinction... and yet again nothing will happen more than big money wasted.

    Cofal Over 9kCofal Over 9k3 måneder siden
  • Three to four times as much solar and / or wind power generating capacity is required to provide reliable base load power as using conventional generating capacity. Nuclear, coal abs natural gas-fired generating capacity are capable of annual load factors of 80%, i.e. operating continuously at 80% of nameplate capacity., Solar and wind power operate at 20% to 25% of nameplate capacity on a daily and annual average Grid interconnections should be made to time zones to the west of where power is consumed. Draw power at night from where the Sun is shining. Interconnections also should cross the equator so that power can be drawn during winter from the opposite hemisphere where it is summer. I'm surprised that the New World Order does not advocate for a power grid fashioned after the British Empire at its peak, "The Sun never sets on the British Empire." Doing so would create the interdependence which is an objective of the NWO.

    Allen LoserAllen Loser3 måneder siden
  • "The chance of flood is rising" Flawless🤣

    Prf. kopperfieldPrf. kopperfield3 måneder siden
  • Another solution is for property owners in at--risk areas to combine resources through a special taxing district to fund construction and maintenance of sea walls of whatever height they believe necessary. Don't pass the bill for protecting *YOUR* property on to those who did not purchase property at risk of being under water in the future. Glaciers will melt and ocean levels will rise with, or without, the assistance of Mankind. That is what happens at the end of an ice age.

    Allen LoserAllen Loser3 måneder siden
  • There is an easy, three step solution a) Move to higher ground if you believe that your property will be underwater in the future. b) Allow for-profit flood insurance companies to charge premiums based upon full actuarial risk. Eliminate federal flood insurance at premiums which do not cover the risk. c) Do not bail out those who are uninsured.

    Allen LoserAllen Loser3 måneder siden
  • This prediction just in - there will be weather in 2050.

    ScottyScotty3 måneder siden
  • I can’t wait when New York goes underwater Tehe the world will be healthier

    The company TvThe company Tv3 måneder siden
  • How much has the subway sunk since it was built? The sea isn't the only thing moving. The ground moves all the time. Areas here in Florida have dropped something like 6 inches due to pumping fresh water out of the ground.

    GeoFry3GeoFry33 måneder siden
  • We can only hope

    GeoFry3GeoFry33 måneder siden
  • O.4 and 0.8mm per year means 12mm to 24mm by 2050.

    Baron VillanuevaBaron Villanueva3 måneder siden
  • Assuming climate change is an initial fallacy. There is no evidence for it.

    Cassio BanquoCassio Banquo3 måneder siden
  • Wait a minute. Obama bought a home in Martha’s Vineyard that will be under water after watching this story. I guess he is not to concerned about the ocean rising.

    patpat3 måneder siden
    • The same area that was supposed to be flooded by now according to Al Gore.

      herrschaftg35herrschaftg353 måneder siden
  • So don't Put Tiny Houses on Trailers, build it on Pontons. And a few good anchors with Long chains.

    FjeldfrossFjeldfross4 måneder siden
  • Alternatively, we could stop the sea level rise by placing a 2000 km diameter mirror at the L1 Lagrange point between the Earth and the sun, which will cool the ocean by 1% to entirely eliminate the effect of greenhouse gases.

    Evan NibbeEvan Nibbe4 måneder siden
  • My dude got a little aggressive here and it kinda made me listen

    Ripudude Luke snowdenRipudude Luke snowden4 måneder siden
  • I'll bet you all the tea in china the sea level in the year 2050 will only be, at most, a couple of inches above what it is now.

    Steven BradfordSteven Bradford4 måneder siden
  • “Free 500 People” Lol.

    Ninja Nerd Student #69Ninja Nerd Student #694 måneder siden
  • The Passive aggressiveness in this video 😂🙌

    FurnFurn4 måneder siden
  • 2:42 😂💀

    FurnFurn4 måneder siden
  • Whenever a yes/no question is made into a title or headline, the answer is invariably “no”.

    David JDavid J4 måneder siden
  • Nah, us government thinks world domination, war and power are more important than save couple million New Yorkers

    T YT Y4 måneder siden
  • humans are accelerating climate change,fossil fuels will stil be used for decades and also fossil cars,forests will still be cutt down,humans just can't get rid off their greediness

    George IonescuGeorge Ionescu4 måneder siden
  • climate change is ireversible,human race is going to extinction

    George IonescuGeorge Ionescu4 måneder siden
  • Sea level rise in NYC not that simple , it a relative measurement ! NY City relative sea-level rate of rise is -2.851 to -4.076 mm/yr. NY City GNSS subsidence is -2.151 to -3.076 mm/yr. NY City absolute sea level rate of rise is 0.7 to 1.0 mm/yr. Climate change or not NYC going down ! It geological ! at 2 to 4 times rate of any climate change rate changes . It unclear what measurement you using if you fail to include subsidence this very bad engineering ! When you use climate modeling you better use the correct assumption in the modeling RCP ( representative concentration pathway ) . If you using 8.5 RCP UN BS number " business a usually " that coal consumption tripling think again we should have seen a 30 % increase in usage by now the true number is 10 % decline globally a 40 % difference . The true path way is closer to RCP 2.6 . By the way new UN replacement for RCP will have a six fold increase coal consumption as highest assumption . Garbage in you get garbage out of the models.

    Alfred WinklerAlfred Winkler4 måneder siden
  • One solution to the problem would be just build New New York above the ruins of Old New York

    MajorohminusMajorohminus4 måneder siden
  • Yes.

    William H.William H.4 måneder siden
  • Cost for Proper Disaster Management: $10M Local government: "It's too costly, also maybe we won't need it' **Disaster hits**: brought $30M+ worth of damages to property and wounded tens of people Local government: "how was I supposed this was about to happen??"

    Ralph SaavedraRalph Saavedra4 måneder siden
  • New Orleans ain't the only thing that's sinking man. Swimming will soon no longer be an option.

    Angus OsbòrneAngus Osbòrne4 måneder siden
  • There is something beautiful about these satanic cities getting flooded.

    Project RetoldProject Retold4 måneder siden
  • I was under the impression that sea level rise due to heat was a function of ice melting at the poles rather than the thermal expansion of water.

    superdupercop18superdupercop184 måneder siden
    • Both are significant contributors.

      SonicVenom829SonicVenom8294 måneder siden
  • Let's just quarry the ocean and bring the soil back to higher grounds. 🤣🤣🤣

    Leon EsperanzaLeon Esperanza4 måneder siden
  • Real Engineering 25 billion dollars isn't that much It's less than 4% of the military budget

    Samuel WangSamuel Wang4 måneder siden
  • 2:00 this graph is garbage. Random picked dates on the bottom.

    Ray RayRay Ray4 måneder siden
  • In all these predictions, no-one has been able to tell us when the climate was not changing. In the last thousand years, nothing in geological terms, it has been both significantly warmer and cooler than now.

    Ian HollandsIan Hollands4 måneder siden
  • Well one can only hope

    ComradeKommisarComradeKommisar4 måneder siden
  • Even if Trump does deny climate change, he has one thing right: We got to build a wall.

    Cristiano MarinelliCristiano Marinelli5 måneder siden
  • You really think that will happened 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

    Deshawn TaylorDeshawn Taylor5 måneder siden
  • After seeing this I remember Aquaman movie 😂😂😂😂😂

    Ujjwal KumarUjjwal Kumar5 måneder siden
  • Conspiracy theorist: The "actual" reason why the sea level's are rising: Is all the trash we are throwing into it is filling it up. Adding a new island in the sea ought to do something.

    MikaelMikael5 måneder siden
    • I love how these climate alarmists always ignore the billions of liters of displaced sea water due to manmade objects. Yet they think 1*C is going to replicate Waterworld.

      herrschaftg35herrschaftg353 måneder siden
  • Unless I have been in china too long why not ho bug big or go home Why not float the city haha

    Speedy OSpeedy O6 måneder siden
  • You should really change your channel name to “science fiction engineering” to better suit your content.

    cokechangcokechang6 måneder siden
  • Ya but where da fawk did we get all dis water from

    BestBeast 19BestBeast 196 måneder siden
  • The water level may be rising in New York but is going down somewhere else. They have been major storms back in the day . Storms are not anything new Sandy happened before . it has nothing to do with pollution or anything else that's just how the world works.

    Ansche FinkAnsche Fink6 måneder siden
  • I'm buying scuba gear right now, ready to explore the treasures in the national marine sanctuary in Central Park. Just hope no one is surprised when they see the Statue of Liberty covered 1/2 way with silt.

    thomas aquinasthomas aquinas6 måneder siden
  • New York would have the money for projects like this if they actually taxed large corporations & the ultra-wealthy properly, instead of middle-class individuals.

    JustSomebodyJustSomebody6 måneder siden
  • nothing in this video would stop new york from being underwater 2050, there solutions are for tsunamis and hurricanes not for sea level rise from melting ice and climate change. so even if they spent 500 billion on sea wall defence it wouldn't help with climate change at all. they would have to completely close off the new york from the sea.

    vennthraxvennthrax6 måneder siden
  • Well, it might remove the smell of urine

    HissmannenHissmannen6 måneder siden
  • An excellent and interesting episode, please also check out this informative lecture notown.info/two/video/vN2OjJucldehz7M.html

    BDJ MBDJ M7 måneder siden
  • Is NASA still the best source for measured water levels.

    JasonJason7 måneder siden
  • Well, year by year ¡ breath worse, and not by smoking..,

    ALBER PAJARESALBER PAJARES7 måneder siden
    • In my twenties ¡ used to be minutes and minutes under water without suply,..

      ALBER PAJARESALBER PAJARES7 måneder siden
    • ¡’Ve been always a monster in breath-resistance so it’s frustrating for me..,

      ALBER PAJARESALBER PAJARES7 måneder siden
    • And ¡’m astmatic from some years ago..,

      ALBER PAJARESALBER PAJARES7 måneder siden
    • ¡’M doing exercises to improve my lungs but need surgery in my nose cause obstructed conducts, etc,..

      ALBER PAJARESALBER PAJARES7 måneder siden
  • Oh god I hope they settle in a fly over state.

    uMe & The DoctoruMe & The Doctor7 måneder siden
  • Let's hope so !

    Mark AnthonyMark Anthony7 måneder siden
  • So water rise when it warms?

    June KimminJune Kimmin7 måneder siden
    • Not to the degree that they are claiming.

      herrschaftg35herrschaftg353 måneder siden
  • I'd be more convinced by Al Gore and Obamas claims of rising sea levels if they would both STOP BUYING BEACH FRONT MANSIONS.

    Devin HallsworthDevin Hallsworth8 måneder siden
  • I do hope so... maybe gouverments would then care more about the the environment..

    Cristian I.Cristian I.8 måneder siden
  • To cool the oceans hypothesis: Our oceans that surround our planet is not unlike a radiator in a car. Take Panama and cut it in half. Allow the cold water thermohaline current to flow.

    Larry BoothLarry Booth8 måneder siden
NOtown